We are so back! Read here about the downtime and security incident. Registered members can now search up to three tags at once!

Comments

[hidden]

kafuki said in comment #2644362:

I was busy then, and now it's only 8 am, I'll change the tags now

If you don't have time to add tags, then you don't have time to upload either. If you were busy, then just don't upload it until you're not busy and can actually tag your posts.

Show 4 more comments
[hidden]

OliveOil said in comment #2644259:

I mean, the character is canonically transgender, and those look identical to early-hrt breast growth, so yeah. Small breasts are still breasts.

Except there's plenty of art of guys like that that are still intended to be viewed as male. Bridget is no exception; plenty of art of her as male was made even after she was revealed to be transgender (and she never physically transitioned as far as I know). I don't know why they're sometimes drawn to look like breasts while the character is meant to be male at the same time, but that's just how it is. Unless the artist said Bridget in this image has physically transitioned, we don't have any reason to assume that is the case. There just isn't enough evidence to warrant changing the tags.

[hidden]

Blank_User said in comment #2644271:

Except there's plenty of art of guys like that that are still intended to be viewed as male. Bridget is no exception; plenty of art of her as male was made even after she was revealed to be transgender (and she never physically transitioned as far as I know). I don't know why they're sometimes drawn to look like breasts while the character is meant to be male at the same time, but that's just how it is. Unless the artist said Bridget in this image has physically transitioned, we don't have any reason to assume that is the case. There just isn't enough evidence to warrant changing the tags.

I believe it was determined that artist intent doesn't matter when tagging this character on this site. It goes by a "looks not lore" basis. Though for what it is worth, I believe this artist has used she/her in the past for this character.
To me this character has clearly female secondary sexual characteristics and looks like a girl with a dick, not a guy. I know there's a lot of difficulty tagging a character such as this, who was previously a femboy and then developed into a trans woman, but I believe fem tags are appropriate for any drawing of bridget with breasts.

[hidden]

OliveOil said in comment #2644274:

I believe it was determined that artist intent doesn't matter when tagging this character on this site. It goes by a "looks not lore" basis. Though for what it is worth, I believe this artist has used she/her in the past for this character.

Correct, the artist's intent would not be enough. My point was that it didn't seem to meet even that standard and it looks no different than any other "trap" character with a puffy chest.

To me this character has clearly female secondary sexual characteristics and looks like a girl with a dick, not a guy. I know there's a lot of difficulty tagging a character such as this, who was previously a femboy and then developed into a trans woman, but I believe fem tags are appropriate for any drawing of bridget with breasts.

Would you say the same for Otori Tan, who's chest often looks just as developed? Should we be switching those to genderswap (mtf) too, even knowing that puffy chests is part of the fetish? Can you reliably tell the difference between actual breasts and puffy chests? If so, would trap fans agree with your categorization?

[hidden]

Would you say the same for Otori Tan, who's chest often looks just as developed? Should we be switching those to genderswap (mtf) too, even knowing that puffy chests is part of the fetish? Can you reliably tell the difference between actual breasts and puffy chests? If so, would trap fans agree with your categorization?

That character isn't canonically a woman like bridget -But honestly, yes, if this site were applying the looks not lore thing fully. Men don't usually look like women with fully developed breasts.
As for puffy chest, I think context and the gender of the character matters under the current rules.

Updated by OliveOil

[hidden]

OliveOil said in comment #2644299:

That character isn't canonically a woman like bridget -But honestly, yes, if this site were applying the looks not lore thing fully. Men don't usually look like women with fully developed breasts.
As for puffy chest, I think context and the gender of the character matters under the current rules.

Canonically, Bridget is still physically male last I checked. And Bridget has been drawn with a puffy chest many, many times with that assumption in mind. The trap fetish intentionally blurs these lines by getting as close to a feminine appearance as possible without actually changing the character's sex.

That's why most posts like this wouldn't be tagged 1girl. If the puffy chest phenomenon didn't exist, then you could make a stronger case for Bridget having breasts in this image. But I doubt most people into femboys will see the difference between this and puffy chest. If they're that close in appearance, than we can't reasonably conclude that Bridget is physically female (or a futanari) in this image.

You argued that she looked like she was in the early stages of hormone replacement therapy, meaning she would still be physically male. If all she's developed is what looks identical to a puffy chest on your average trap post, then I'd say she hadn't physically transitioned enough for it to count yet. If the evidence is weak, then we should err towards the default, which is to tag her as 1boy.

Date Uploader Fireminer Rating General
Tags
willfin eiyuu_densetsu sora_no_kiseki sora_no_kiseki_tc agate_crosner aina_holden alan_richard anelace_elfead campanella_(eiyuu_densetsu) cassius_bright don_capua estelle_bright josette_capua joshua_bright julia_schwarz karin_astray kevin_graham kloe_rinz kyle_capua leonhardt_(eiyuu_densetsu) olivert_reise_arnor renne_(eiyuu_densetsu) ries_argent scherazard_harvey tita_russell zin_vathek commentary_request dated_commentary highres making-of_available 6+boys 6+girls :d :o ahoge alcohol animal_costume antenna_hair arm_up arms_under_breasts bare_shoulders bare_tree bat_wings black_choker black_cross_tie black_dress black_gloves black_hair black_horns black_veil black_wings blonde_hair blue_eyes braid braided_ponytail brown_eyes brown_hair building candy chibi chibi_on_head child choker claw_pose cloak closed_eyes closed_mouth collared_shirt cross_scar cross_tie crossed_arms cup curtained_hair dark-skinned_female dark_skin demon_horns detached_sleeves double-parted_bangs dress drinking_glass everyone expressionless facial_mark flying food forehead_mark frankenstein's_monster_costume full_moon gem ghost glass gloves goggles goggles_on_head green_eyes green_hair green_headband grey_eyes grey_hair grey_pants guimpe hair_between_eyes hair_intakes hair_slicked_back hairband halloween halloween_bucket halloween_costume hand_up happy_halloween hat headband hexagram holding holding_candy holding_cup holding_food holding_halloween_bucket holding_hands holding_lollipop holding_wand hood hood_up hooded_cloak horns jack-o'-lantern large_hat lollipop long_hair long_sleeves looking_at_another looking_at_viewer low_ponytail mascot_costume medium_hair moon moonlight multiple_boys multiple_girls mummy_costume night nun nun_headdress object_through_head on_head one_eye_closed open_hand open_mouth orange_hair outdoors pants parted_bangs pendant_choker pink_hair ponytail priest puffy_long_sleeves puffy_short_sleeves puffy_sleeves purple_eyes red_gem red_hair scar scar_on_cheek scar_on_face screw_in_head shirt short_dress short_sleeves sidelocks sitting sky sleeveless sleeveless_dress smile spiked_hair standing star_(symbol) stitched_face stitches stole swirl_lollipop tower tree twintails v v_over_eye vampire_costume veil very_long_braid vestments wand waving white_cloak white_dress white_gloves white_shirt wine wine_glass wings witch witch_hat wolf_costume yellow_eyes
1 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50