The ONLY character now not accounted for tagging-wise is the bird at the top, above Mary O. I feel like I've seen it before but I can't remember.

EDIT: Nevermind, just remembered it's from Mario Maker. Named Yamamura.

Had time to kill so I decided to come back here to try my hand at mass annotating. First time so please no bully.

Character names are listed along with their debut game. Should be noted that this usually does not take into account the current design the character is wearing, which is why the actual copyright tags may differ. For example, Captain Syrup debuted in Super Mario Land 3: Wario Land but the design she's wearing is from Wario Land: Shake It!, Donkey Kong and Pauline are sporting their Donkey Kong (Game Boy) redesigns, Koopalings are in their New Super Mario Bros. Wii designs, etc.

Exceptions are the Undodog and Mega Mushroom, who I felt their modern incarnations are so different that I put both debuts to be safe, and the magikoopa who is sporting the broomstick which is (mostly, but not always) a unique trait of Kamek so I opted for him and Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island instead of just Magikoopa & Super Mario World. Let me know if you have anything about this formatting bothers you.